Cart 0

ERSTWILDER

Sort by

NEW!

A novelty enamel pin shaped like a stack of books, styled as a birthday cake with gold metal outlines and colorful book spines in pink, orange, purple, and white. The books feature text such as 'RISE from the BREAD', 'MURDEROUS MIXOLOGY', 'Deadly Desserts', and 'BARBE-BOO'.

Midnight Mischief Midnight Library Enamel Pin

Regular price $17.00

NEW!

A gold metal enamel pin featuring a cartoon black cat wearing an orange pumpkin top as a hat and sitting in a jack-o'-lantern

Midnight Mischief Cat O'Lantern Enamel Pin

Regular price $17.00

NEW!

A pair of dangling skeleton-shaped earrings in a pale mint green glow-in-the-dark finish, shown on a plain white background with a green starburst sticker that reads 'I GLOW IN THE DARK!'.

Halloween Essentials Dancing Skeletons Dangle Earrings - Glow in the Dark

Regular price $16.00

NEW!

A pair of black skeleton dangle earrings with silver-tone fishhook wires, shown against a plain white background.

Halloween Essentials Dancing Skeletons Dangle Earrings - Black

Regular price $16.00

NEW!

A pair of dangling glitter white acrylic resin skeleton earrings with silver-toned fishhook wires, shown on a plain white background.

Halloween Essentials Dancing Skeletons Dangle Earrings - White

Regular price $16.00

NEW!

A pair of dangle earrings shaped like cute ghost figures in pale mint green, with black eyes and black shadow lines. A green starburst sticker in the top left corner reads 'I GLOW IN THE DARK!'.

Halloween Essentials Ghostie Dangle Earrings - Glow in the Dark

Regular price $16.00

NEW!

LAST ONE!

A layered acrylic resin brooch shaped like a black cauldron with orange and red flames at the bottom, pink bubbly steam at the top, and a small green frog bathing inside. The piece is shown on a plain white background with a soft drop shadow.

Midnight Mischief Spookin' Spa Day Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

LAST ONE!

A colorful floral necklace with four stylized flowers in orange, pink, and purple, all with eyeball centers, and accented with green leaves and a silver chain.

Midnight Mischief Eye Spy Necklace

Regular price $94.00

NEW!

Acrylic resin brooch depicting three colorful flowers with eyeball centers, set against a plain white background.

Midnight Mischief Eye Spy Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

A white skull acrylic resin brooch featuring purple glitter flowers, green leaves, black eye sockets and nose, shown on a plain white background.

Midnight Mischief Shade of Night Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

A moth-shaped glow-in-the-dark acrylic resin brooch on a white background, featuring a green thorax with a black skull motif, purple and pink wings with crescent moon and star details, and a green starburst sticker in the top-left corner that reads 'I GLOW IN THE DARK!'.

Midnight Mischief Flutter By Night Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

Halloween ghost house door acrylic resin brooch with a mint green frame, pink glittery door, orange number 666, black cat silhouette, yellow lanterns, and an orange jack-o'-lantern pumpkin, shown on a white background with a green 'I Glow in the Dark!' badge.

Midnight Mischief Knock, Knock Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

A colorful Halloween haunted house acrylic resin brooch with pink, purple, orange, and white sections, plus pumpkins, bats, a ghost, and a green starburst that says 'I GLOW IN THE DARK!'.

Midnight Mischief Haunted Hideaway Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

acrylic resin brooch depicting the side view of a fluffy orange dog wearing a glitter black cape and top hat, and carrying a jack-o-lantern candy bucket filled with bones in its mouth

Midnight Mischief Count Barkula Brooch

Regular price $44.00

NEW!

A pink and orange glittery teapot and matching teacup with black decorative scrollwork and bats acrylic resin brooch, shown on a plain white background.

Midnight Mischief Spills and Spells Brooch

Regular price $47.00

NEW!

A book stack-shaped acrylic resin brooch featuring book spines in pink, orange, yellow, and white with text reading 'RISE from the BREAD', 'MURDEROUS MIXOLOGY', 'Deadly Desserts', and 'BARBE-BOO' on a plain white background.

Midnight Mischief Midnight Library Brooch

Regular price $44.00

NEW!

A layered acrylic resin brooch featuring an orange cat sitting on top of a pink and orange cabinet television with a glow-in-the-dark green screen showing a moon, stars, and bats, with two knobs at the bottom.

Midnight Mischief Retro Static Brooch

Regular price $44.00

NEW!

A glitter black raven acrylic resin brooch with a lavender witch hat and wing accents.

Midnight Mischief Flirt and Flutter Brooch

Regular price $44.00

A stylized shrimp layered acrylic resin brooch with a gold crown, red body, white-and-black spotted trim, and a small gold cup, shown on a plain white background.

Pascal the King Prawn Brooch

Regular price $44.00

A shrimp-shaped layered acrylic resin brooch with a pink glittery dress, small tiara, and a blue bird accessory, isolated on a white background.

Pascal the Princess Prawn Brooch

Regular price $44.00

A stylized cartoon prawn layered acrylic resin brooch on a plain white background. The prawn is orange with a blue-and-white striped body, a red beret, and holds a pink drink in one claw.

Pascal the Parisian Prawn Brooch

Regular price $44.00

LAST ONE!

A cartoon shrimp acrylic resin brooch with an orange body, wearing a pink party hat with yellow stars and a green floral shirt, holding a tropical drink on a plain white background.

Pascal the Party Prawn Brooch

Regular price $44.00

A scooter-shaped acrylic resin brooch featuring a blue marbled pattern with white stripes, a white headlight with a blue heart, and black handlebars, shown on a plain white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Roman Holiday Brooch

Regular price $44.00

acrylic resin brooch of a green wine bottle with a cork stopper and a decorative label featuring a gold swallow on a brown background, styled with red grapes and a cheese wedge on a white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Rouge ou Blanc? Brooch

Regular price $44.00

A beetle-shaped acrylic resin brooch in marbled greens with and a gold-colored central ridge, shown against a plain white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Nature's Noel Brooch

Regular price $40.00

"Rainbow Ruff" rainbow striped arch bodied dog layered resin brooch

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Rainbow Ruff Brooch

Regular price $44.00

acrylic resin brooch depicting two yellow daffodils with orange centers and green leaves, shown on a plain white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Garden Goddess Daffodil Brooch

Regular price $47.00

acrylic resin brooch of a triangular piece of bread covered in colorful sprinkles with a bit taken out of it

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Fairy Bread Brooch

Regular price $40.00

acrylic resin brooch of two stylized green birds with yellow heads perched on a brown branch, with blue flower accents, shown on a plain white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Best Budgies Brooch

Regular price $47.00

"Puss in Books" bespectacled reading cat textured brown and glitter pink layered resin brooch

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Puss in Books Brooch

Regular price $44.00

acrylic resin brooch depicting an owl wearing round purple-rimmed glasses, perched on top of a purple and white book with a red ribbon bookmark. The owl has a white body, brown head, and a marbled brown wing, set against a plain white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Studious Snow Owl Brooch

Regular price $40.00

acrylic resin brooch of a pink cat wearing blue glasses and bow tie

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Elissa the Indie Cat Brooch

Regular price $40.00

black, red, and white cockatoo perched on a branch acrylic resin brooch, shown against a plain white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Carnaboo the Cockatoo Brooch

Regular price $40.00

A fox face acrylic resin brooch with a red background and a floral pattern in lavender, orange, and purple, featuring solid black ear and nose areas, shown on a white background.

Erstwilder 15th Birthday Collection Brida the Botanical Brooch

Regular price $40.00

gold acrylic resin star and moon motif oval dangle earrings

Fairy Tales Essentials Moonlight Dangle Earrings - Gold

Regular price $12.00

blue with metallic gold stars wizard hat shaped resin brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Wizard Hat Simplified Mini Brooch

Regular price $23.00

white, yellow, and metallic gold resin candelabra with lit candles brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Candelabra Simplified Mini Brooch

Regular price $20.00

red apple with green leaves acrylic resin brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Apple Simplified Mini Brooch

Regular price $20.00

brown acrylic resin grandfather clock shaped brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Clock Simplified Mini Brooch

Regular price $20.00

LAST ONE!

metallic gold resin with red diamonds crown-shaped brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Crown Simplified Mini Brooch

Regular price $20.00

open book with "Once upon a time" text and a red bookmark acrylic resin brooch on a white background

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Open Book Simplified Mini Brooch

Regular price $20.00

Pink unicorn earrings with hearts on a white background

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Magical Ally Earrings

Regular price $47.00

Beast of Beauty and the Beast wearing green holding red rose layered acrylic resin brooch with blue sky oval shape

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Accursed Gentleman Brooch

Regular price $47.00

LAST ONE!

swan with colorful feathers layered acrylic resin brooch on a white background

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Maiden Curse Brooch

Regular price $44.00

Goldilocks wearing blue dress, holding a teddy bear and sipping porridge layered acrylic resin brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Just Right Brooch

Regular price $47.00

Sleeping Beauty princess with long blonde hair, wearing a blue dress, surrounded by flowers on a black background layered acrylic resin brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Beauty Sleep Brooch

Regular price $47.00

red haired princess on stack of pastel mattresses with green pea layered acrylic resin brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Delicate Sensibilities Brooch

Regular price $47.00

pink-haired Thumbelina character on a pink flower with green leaves layered acrylic resin brooch, shown on a white background

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Pocket Princess Brooch

Regular price $47.00

brown running gingerman layered acrylic resin brooch

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Catch Me If You Can Brooch

Regular price $44.00

Red boot with three colorful elf figures layered acrylic resin brooch on a white background

Pete Cromer Fairy Tales Business Acumen Brooch

Regular price $47.00

←
1
2
3
…
7
→